Wednesday, May 11, 2005

Eehwajang: The Home of President Syngman Rhee


Gate at the Residence of Syngman Rhee

Last Friday my lovely language partner and I went to the home of 이승만, known to the West as "Syngman Rhee," the first President of South Korea. It is now a small museum, known, in Korean, as 이화장. I first was made aware of the existence of this place from Shaun's blog post on the subject. Since Shaun has already given directions to this fascinating museum, I won't do so, and in any case my language partner (who lives sixty seconds from my home), and I went up through Naksan park behind our homes and down to the museum, thus approaching from the opposite direction. My language partner stumbled across the site by accident some weeks ago, so she was my guide. To get there, we had to go down from Naksan Park along a narrow alley:


En route to the house of Syngman Rhee

Before proceding further, you can read the sign, like I did:

Sign at the Gate

As you can see from the sign, this home was the residence of a famous scholar long before it became the residence of the first President of South Korea. To get in, you have to push open the gate yourself, and close it behind you.


President Rhee's House

So this is the surprisingly modest home of the first President of South Korea. Although for a house in Seoul it is quite nicely laid out and spacious, even now, it certainly is not something one would expect a President of a country to live in. When the leaders of many smaller, poor countries live in squalor, President Rhee lived in a modest dwelling of some historical significance, until his move to The Blue House, which remains the Presidential mansion.

The occupant of the house did have some nice things, like a pocket watch, for example, but the lifestyle he lived seemed to have been merely what one might think of as "upper middle class." Now perhaps someone will say, "but South Korea was poor at that time, and couldn't afford much." However, a simple online tour of the country's Chosun dynasty's Gyeongbokgung Palace--or any of the other Chosun dynastic dwellings--quickly rebuts this. I suppose his standard of living went up when he lived in the Blue House, but I'm sure he was no Saddam Hussein.

The artefactual qualities of the site are heightened by the interesting collection of historic black and white photographs:




In the next two pictures, you can see the Presidential study, quite a modest affair. There is on the desk a picture of the late President pecking, with two fingers, at his typewriter.


Dr. Rhee's Study


The Presidential Typewriter

President Rhee lived for some years in the United States, earning an M.A. from Harvard and a Ph.D. from Princeton. He was a reader and author.


Books in the Atrium

Some of the books, pictured above, were authored by Dr. Rhee. In one book, published in 1941, he warned of the coming aggression of the Japanese against the USA. He has a discussion of Hawaii in that context in the book, which I browsed briefly.

The President was also a devout Christian:


"Christian Endeavor Prayer Meeting Topics, 1907"

Dr. Rhee was also a man of culture who liked to write Chinese poems, many of which he wrote while in prison. His personal screen contains (one [or more?]) such poems in his own calligraphy:




In South Korea, personal seals have been a traditional way to affix one's signature to documents. Here are the first President's seals:


Seals


Some Personal Effects

Syngman Rhee lived the life of an exile for a great part of his life. During the Japanese occupation, he lived in Japan-occupied China, from where he continued his activist activities. To avoid being arrested by the Japanese, he wore this disguise of Chinese clothing:




This outfit stands in sharp contrast to the comment of one of my adult student that Rhee supported Japan after Korean independence. In fact, President Rhee was roundly condemned by many of my adult students, and is not popular in his own nation. I regret this, and think this complaint inapppropriate, in light of the man's personal sacrifices caused by his love for his country. He suffered exile and fear and lived daily with these realities--something most of today's Koreans cannot identify with.

The next picture shows part of a beautiful painting given to Rhee by Mrs. Chiang Kai-Shek. Rhee met Chiang Kai Shek twice--once in China (before the Maoist revolution), and once in Taiwan.


Detail of Painting

Syngman Rhee also freed anti-communist prisoners, and was involved in the fight against Communism in Vietnam. An anti-communist Ukrainian group gave him these gavels:


Gavels presented by a Ukrainian democratic movement

As President, he visited Japan twice, the first time as the guest of General MacArthur, the second time at the invitation of the Japanese Prime Minister. I think the President realized the importance of forgiveness and starting anew. Meanwhile, it is clear that South Korea has abandoned the alliances which were so important to Mr. Rhee. While many Koreans consider the United States and Japan to be enemies, the country is cozening up to both North Korea and China while ignoring Taiwan, a country which is resisting, with the aid of the US and Japan, China's moves at aggression on that democratic country. "You've come a long, way, baby." This saddened me, and I wonder why the country has changed.

While I know very little of Korean history, certainly, the administration personnel of the Rhee government is widely viewed as being corrupt. That being said, a few of my adult students felt that the man himself had a good heart, and it was the people around him who were not serving him and the country to the best of their ability.

The complaint has been voiced that when the Japanese took over Korea, many of the Chosun dynasty's aristocracy supported Japan--and these people were allowed to remain in position by President Rhee after independence. The comparison was drawn by one adult student of mine with Germany, which she said purged the Nazis after WWII. However, I think this complaint is invalid. In the first place, the German post-war purge was not complete, and in the second place, Germany had been a developed country for decades. The country could thus afford to replace many civil servants who were Nazis with others who had similar expertise in civil affairs. I don't think South Korea had this luxury, as it was a relatively poor country even under the Chosun dynasty. For a President of a poor country which has made so quick a leap to first world status in quality of living to be so dishonored by his own people is both tragic and fascinating. Today, all that remains of his earlier honors may be these medals:


Medals from South Korea

On the other hand, the widespread condemnation of Rhee must have some basis in reality. Many Koreans feel that he was too pro-US (he once organized a national campaign urging the US to keep its troops on the penninsula). A potential rival died under mysterious circumstances. Perhaps there are other issues of which I am unaware. I wonder if the memory of Rhee is tarnished by today's anti-Americanism, or if today's anti-Americanism is a function of the alleged Rhee government corruption and insufficient purge of pro-Japanese Chosun administrators.

Syngman Rhee married a foreigner, a lady from Austria. Since I hope to marry a Korean woman one day, this alone gives him a special place in my heart. The lady he married was an Austrian, Francesca Donner.

You can see Mrs. Donner's clothes and native language in the next photograph:


Mrs. Donner's clothing in box with German writing

Mrs. Donner, like her husband, was a frugal lady. She had her children conserve their things by not giving them fresh pencils very often.


Stubby Pencils saved by a frugal Mrs. Donner

Mrs. Donner and her husband eventually left the country again, at the sudden end of the long presidency of Dr. Rhee. They settled in a home in Hawaii. I saw a picture of this home in the museum, and was astonished at how small it was. The next picture shows the very ordinary table--similar to ones I've seen in old people's houses--from that house.




Outside the house, there is on the grounds a small building containing a wood-storage room, and two other thinking rooms, both spartan and bare.







The garden at the site is not huge, but it is beautiful and peaceful.




A commemorative statue stands in the garden, which yours truly liked enough to be photographed with.




The subject of the next picture, a small damaged Buddhist statue, was fascinating to me because the President was a devout Christian. Perhaps it is a metaphor for the memory of Syngman Rhee.


Buddhist Statue (shown larger than real size), in the garden

Syngman Rhee's last days were lived in exile in the company of his wife in his tiny house in Hawaii. Judging from this photograph, I think, thanks to her companionship, he enjoyed his days to the end.



--
Postscript:
Out of all the places I've been in Korea, including its temples and palaces, this place remains for me the most interesting. It is also special because of the company of my friend. I hope that through this little post the memory of Mr. Syngman will be rehabilitated, at least for some of his countrymen; I must say, however, that this was not the purpose of my visit, as prior to the visit I knew only that Syngman Rhee was the country's first President. Seeing the modest means and the cultured interests and sincerity of this man through the museum made a great impression on me. Finally, I solicit the corrections and comments of anyone more knowledgable than I in the Comments. Also, I signed the guestbook at the museum; if you simply feel like leaving a guestbook type comment here, please feel free to do so. Thank you for visiting, online, Eewhajang. Goodbye.

16 Comments:

Blogger Shaun said...

Amazing review.. I wish I took more pictures.. but was under the impression from the person there I wasn't allowed. Nice to see that we were.

It was an amazing place. And does rival the palaces/temples because of the educational value. I want to find the time to read his book.

From humble beginnings come great things.. and the experience in Eehwajang proves that... (and thanks for the links).

1:59 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Nathan

I found you from posting on Stephen Taylor’s site.

Wow, that’s quite a post you have today. Well done.

Before retiring, I oversaw an office in SK and visited a couple of times.
My staff was young, energetic and hungry for success. Great to see. They would make the interesting point that there was no way they would ever agree to merging with NK and make the mistake Germany did to its economy. I can understand their concern, but hope a merger someday comes about for selfish security reasons.

Like you, I’m a fiscal conservative, a hawk and a “flexible” social liberal. Nice to see young people not making the same socialist errors my baby boomer generation has committed. The aggressiveness of Koreans for success is an example of what motivates me to remove the Liberal dreamers who have the warped idea Canada is ready for this century.

Good luck and I’ll check in once in awhile.

nomdenet

2:17 AM  
Blogger Sewing said...

Hi, Nathan:

A fascinating post. I don't think the low regard in which Rhee is widely held is directly related to the current political climate, however. He was forced to resign in 1960 in the face of longstanding, widespread discontent, and South Korea was in no better shape economically when he resigned that it had been in 1945.

It was under Park Chung-hee (1961-1979) that the bulk of South Korea's economic transformation took place, from one of the poorest countries in Asia to a wealthy, industrialized nation with a large middle class.

Of course, Park—who came to power through a military coup in 1961—has his fair share of detractors today as well, and there is a much more direct relationship between how Park regarded today and the current political climate than is the case for Rhee.

2:51 AM  
Blogger Sewing said...

...To Rhee's credit, however, he did work tirelessly for decades for Korean independence.

3:07 AM  
Anonymous Dander said...

Nathan, great images. Not sure you can find any detailed photos like yours on the net.

Did the museum mention anything about Ahn Chang-Ho, another exiled political figure? Ahn and Rhee created a provisional government in China in the early 1900s. Like Rhee, Ahn also lived in the U.S. (S. California) with his family, but was later arrested by the Japanese in Shanghai and died in prison. I think Ahn would have been Korea's first president had he lived. He was very well liked. Ahn's oldest son, Philip, was a Hollywood movie star who ironically played mostly Japanese roles, and his most notable role as the master on the tv series 'Kung Fu.'

4:38 AM  
Blogger Nathan said...

Hi Shaun, thanks for the kind words--and it was my pleasure to link to you. Credit was given where credit was due, my blog-friend! As for the pictures, I'm surprised that you ran into trouble; that's too bad. Perhaps the pretty young lady who accompanied me charmed the curator.

nomdenet, I appreciated your comments, and it's nice that you found my blog via my comment on Stephen Taylor's site. I do hope you check back now and then. Like you, I have found South Korean young people to be quite wonderful.

Sewing, I appreciate your comments on Syngman Rhee. For the country not to improve much (if at all), in 15 years is fairly damning--but then, look at India. An Indian friend in his 40's says India didn't improve at all from independence to the 80's. Perhaps Syngman was a born activist, and was not so adept at governing. Yes, I knew he was forced out, although I think he went less unwillingly than he might have--one or two other South Korean Presidents held on for dear life, I think. If you know anything more about Rhee, please feel free to write more.

Dander, thanks for the kind words. I'm quite pleased to take pictures that are not available on the 'net; I do that on purpose, actually. I don't remember the museum mentioning the name of the activist you mentioned, but he sounds interesting.

9:27 AM  
Blogger Shaun said...

I don't want to get into growth theory economics either (because I hated the class). But, would be willing to submit a simple metaphor used to explain economic growth... but can make it simple..

The metaphor was developed to explain why there is such a disparity between the "well-developed" countries and the "undeveloped" countries with few in the middle... and was called the escalator effect. Countries have an inherently difficult time getting "on" but move quickly to the top.. the concept was created in response to the Asian Tigers. But, the question is when they got on the escalator.. did Rhee get them on and Park enjoy the benefits of good timing? Or was it indeed Park? That'd actually be interesting to research.. if not almost impossible to figure out with my limited knowledge in the area.

Regardless, the first step was establishing the institutions and ensuring their functionality... it is much easier to achieve greatness when standing on the shoulders of giants. And I don't want to lessen Park's work because he had to have done amazing things is well... but I give Rhee significant credit given that he started from Square 1.

And about Francesca, I did find it interesting that the first Korean president married a Weigook considering it is frowned upon so heavily here.

1:13 PM  
Blogger Nathan said...

About Rhee laying the groundwork, I'm glad you mentioned that, Shaun, as I had been wondering about the same question. I'm glad that you folks liked this post, because I certainly enjoyed putting it together!

12:21 AM  
Blogger Sewing said...

Hi, Nathan:

I recall reading that Rhee himself was not corrupt, but that many of the people around him were, which I think is what led to his widespread unpopularity.

He was autocratic and strongly anti-Communist, and in this regard set the stage for the presidents (Park and Chun) who followed him.

But it can certainly be argued that, had a person of less conviction than him been the first president, things might have turned out differently. I am really not enough of an expert to say, and that's speculation anyhow.

Specifically, Rhee was forced to resign because of a student-led uprising in 1960. Yun Bo-seon of the opposition Democratic Party was briefly president, but government was weakened by internal party divisions.

As for Park, he famously lacked self-interest and was quite frugal in his personal life. These factors—and his tenacity in implementing his vision of South Korea as a prosperous country—are what made him popular, and somewhat ameliorated the darker aspects of life under his rule. Nevertheless, there was a strong dissident movement—two of whose leaders were the future presidents Kim Young-sam and Kim Dae-jung—during his years in power, and during the ensuing dictatorship under Chun, culminating in the (again largely student-led) 1987 democracy movement that ushered in modern-day South Korea as we know it.

By the way, after Park staged the coup, he resigned from the army to rule as a civilian president. At least first few presidential elections that he won were democratic; as the years wore on, however, controls on the opposition became tighter and tighter.

Well, how's that for a history lesson? I generally prefer not to discuss politics on blogs (I'm not into heated debates, flamewars, etc.), but at this point, the subject of our discussion is more history than politics, and I am interested in history.

5:24 AM  
Blogger Mike said...

Nathan.....What an entertaining and educational post!

9:47 AM  
Anonymous Jung-Eun said...

Nathan,

great post!!

I think that Rhee was good and honorable man but he didn't have the leadership to pull the country together during the chaotic time after the independence. I believed that he was perceived by Korean people at that time that he was rather disconnected with the people and issues that Korean people were facing. He mostly lived outside of the country before he became president and had a foreign wife. I don't know how true this is, but my mother told me that when Rhee was asked how to solve the rice shortage problem, he responded people should try bread instead.

Anyways, thank you for the detailed review and pictures.

8:20 AM  
Blogger Nathan said...

Sewing, thanks for your (always interesting) further comments.

Mike, glad you enjoyed the post.

Eun Jung, great to hear from you again! By the way, I saw the movie you recommended last night on TV. Your anecdote about Syngman Rhee was hilarious, both to me and to my girlfriend. I think that having a man who spent so much of his time abroad as leader could have both pro's and cons, I guess.

By the way, I've appreciated all the comments on this post, and am impressed with how interested in this man you all are!

4:02 PM  
Blogger Sewing said...

Hi, Nathan:

Anyhow, I enjoyed seeing all the photos. It was almost as good as being there!

2:10 AM  
Blogger Gar said...

Nathan,
Very well done. I enjoyed reading your post and the pics, sorry it took me so long to get over here.

You asked if I knew anything about Syng Man Rhee (http:thebasshole.blogspot.com)

Seems I know a little more now after reading your post.

If you are interested in Korea's fledgling democracy and it's past presidents I highly recommend you read Michael Breen's "The Koreans"

- Thanks for sharing.

9:25 AM  
Blogger flowerful said...

You explore korean more than me! I enjoyed your post a lot. :)

4:38 PM  
Blogger Nathan said...

Hi again, Gar; thanks for the kind words and the recommendation.

Flowerful, glad you liked this post!

9:36 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home